[Seb91]

Originally Posted by Austin101

Thanks for the compliments as always guys, I appreciate them all!




That's because I seriously think we have different rating systems to an extent. You tend to hand out most matches on PPV's or "big matches" *** 3/4 or higher like there candy, Hey it's all good its just your *** 3/4 is like my *** 1/4, I rate a little lower. For me a match can be tremendous and still *** 1/4. For instance if you read my HBK/Kennedy review you'll see I thought it was an excellent match and I gave it 3 stars. A lot of people's ratings on that show are very similar to mine so I doubt im very far off with the consensus.


Edgehead, I never said I was doing SS 07. I have a huge list you can rea that to see what's next on my review list. I wont do the survior series till I get the anthology, same with Slam. It's a good thing I have a shit load of mateial because that will take me right until the Slam Anthology comes out!

RAW IS WAR REVIEW UP in about 6-8 HOURS!

I'm sure it's more our differing views on matches, rather than our rating systems that differ. Actually, I haven't rated a lot of the big main events that high this year. Gave the HHH/Orton matches **1/2 and **3/4, and I gave HHH/JBL/Orton/Cena only ***. A lot of our ratings are very similar.

[Austin101]

Originally Posted by HBK91

I'm sure it's more our differing views on matches, rather than our rating systems that differ. Actually, I haven't rated a lot of the big main events that high this year. Gave the HHH/Orton matches **1/2 and **3/4, and I gave HHH/JBL/Orton/Cena only ***. A lot of our ratings are very similar.

Yeah. that is true I guess and if we disagree on a match it's usually between a half a star or 3/4 at most.

[bigcal]

Good review as usual, Austin! Even though the event isn't that old, the ONLY match I can remember if HBK/Kennedy . I think I had it at *** as well. They had a MUCH better match on Raw after that, which I would say is ***1/2 - ***3/4.

I finally have the bloody TV to myself for most of today, so I can get my third Raw 2000 review done. There are 5 Raws in Jan 00, and I might very well get them all done today if I can cope with writing my reviews down on paper then typing them up .

[Seb91]

Originally Posted by Austin101

Yeah. that is true I guess and if we disagree on a match it's usually between a half a star or 3/4 at most.

Most of those matches from Armageddon I only had 1/4* higher than you. Although I did give Kennedy/Michaels ***1/4-***1/2. There match on RAW though was much better, ****. They had another match on RAW as well where Kennedy pinned Michaels, think I gave it *** or there abouts.

[- AF -]

Wrestlemania 22

Kane/Show v Carlito/Masters ***
MITB II ****
Benoit/JBL **3/4
Edge/Foley ****1/2
Booker/Boogeyman *
Mickie/Trish ***
Taker/Henry **1/2
HBK/McMahon ***1/4
Angle/Orton/Mysterio ***1/2
Candice/Torrie 1/4*
HHH/Cena ***1/2

[bigcal]

Wrestlemania 22

Kane/Show v Carlito/Masters **
MITB II ***1/2
Benoit/JBL ***
Edge/Foley ****1/4
Booker/Boogeyman DUD
Mickie/Trish **3/4
Taker/Henry **
HBK/McMahon ***1/4
Angle/Orton/Mysterio ***1/2
Candice/Torrie DUD
HHH/Cena ****

[Edgehead9812]

Fair ratings their Aussiefan. I'd give boogeyman/Booker a DUD but, Booker deserved better then that. At least he got a world title run later.

[- AF -]

I didnt really think the match was THAT bad. It was a filler, a match to make the card look better.

[The Clique87]

Originally Posted by HBK91

The most overrated match from last year is Orton/Trips. I remember someone giving it ****3/4

In fact, it might've been Clique.

Oh, and it looks like Vengeance is no more, now it's been rebranded to Night of Champions

HHH/Orton LMS **** 1/4

Austin101, the booking and how everything went down is the reason I give the Batista/Undertaker/Edge *** 1/2. Absolute perfect way to exploit the "Master Manipulator" side of Edge. The entire match was just plain entertaining. I agree though it would have been better longer but it was pretty damn good for what it was.

Oh, Kennedy/Michaels Raw(I'm guessing the 1st HD show) *** 1/2

[Taroostyles]

Yeah the triple threat gets pretty varied ratings, about **3/4-**** from what I've seen.