Wrestling Forum banner

Favorite Shield member in 2017?

  • Roman "Overpushed & Despised" Reigns

    Votes: 65 27.8%
  • Seth "Injury-Prone & Generic" Rollins

    Votes: 95 40.6%
  • Dean "Boring & Unmotivated" Ambrose

    Votes: 74 31.6%

Who is your favorite member of The Shield now?

11K views 175 replies 128 participants last post by  joesmith 
#1 · (Edited)
The Shield was highly praised in this forum few years back. Let us look at how far everyone's gone:

Roman Reigns: Overpushed failure, Hated by 80% of the crowd, The lesser Rock, 3 time WWE Champion, 3 time WM main eventer, Retired The Undertaker

Seth Rollins: Injury-prone failure, Character-less geek, Triple H addict, Weak finisher magnet, 2 time WWE Champion, Money in the Bank winner, 1 time WM main eventer, Slayed Triple H "The King"

Dean Ambrose: Lazy and complacent failure, Lunatic Cringe, Mic Disappointment, Lariat King, Jobber to the Stars, 1 time WWE Champion, Money in the Bank winner, Won The Shield Triple Threat

So, who do you pick then?
 
#9 ·
Shitty op? Rollins is a great worker, but most likely to get injured in 1 out of 20 of his matches. How do u even like Rollins, what exactly is he? Kingslayer? Revolving around Triple H? Architect? Revolving around The Shield? Who IS Rollins
 
#7 ·
My favorite Shield member?

I gotta go with the MAN Seth Rollins :rollins

Although Dean Ambrose is cool too :eek:
 
#11 ·
CM Punk
 
#12 ·
Gotta go with Rollins, Dean is a close second.
 
#15 ·
If I'm honest, even in his current state it's come back to being Dean again. For the last year or so it has been Seth, by some way, too. But there's something about Dean. There's a potential there for something great - and it might never happen - but I want it to. A lot. There's just something magnetic about Dean that makes me want to watch, while I feel Seth has become all that he can be, which is beyond what I expected of him, but there's nothing more to show. And Roman... I just can't care.
 
#18 ·
Jobber to Rollins, Reigns, Triple H, Lesnar, Owens, Wyatt, etc. He has a ceiling, he's lower than most of the main eventers in Raw.
 
#19 ·
Wasn´t a fan of the Shield to begin with, so I don´t have a favorite ;)
It could have been Rollins, but that long, boring run as corporate cowardly heel destroyed my interest in him, it´s gonna take him a long time to rebuild that, but he keeps getting injured.
Ambrose just phones it in week in and week out, so nope.
And Reigns..Well, you said favorite member, so he shouldn´t be mentioned.
 
#20 ·
Always has been, and always will be, Dean Ambrose.

But I refuse to use your poll because it's a piece of shit lame attempt at being funny by being negative for no reason. You suck and shouldn't be allowed to make polls anymore.

 
#21 ·
Which part of my poll is false? :eek:
 
#22 ·
Right now its Seth. His recent promos against HHH strengthened him as a character at least for now, and he's the most interesting of the three at the moment.

Ambrose is one of those guys that I look at and think he would have been a much better character in the Attitude Era. His natural personality would have suited that era more and the character would have had more of an edge. Right now, he's just an idiot goofball.

And I keep saying it, but Reigns would make a great heel. The fans hate him and he comes across like a smug prick on TV. Its right there guys! But no, they have to ram him down our throats which only makes the fans hate him more.
 
#37 ·
Stupid poll description is stupid.

Reigns. His character is starting to shape up and he's consistent in the ring. My one issue with him is that he's a bit redundant, both promo wise and move wise (You can do a Superman Punch. We get it!), but otherwise I enjoy what he brings to the table.

Rollins is so bland now despite so much material to work with at hand, and hasn't done particularly well in either alignment. Plus his ring skills have taken quite the nose dive, but that's because of injury so I can't fault him for that. The writers have zero clue how to handle his face run and you can tell by how pointless and all over the place his promos and segments are.

Ambrose is just...ugh. Never had good wrestling skills. His character got old a year ago. He's lazy and phones it in 90% of the time. Everyone made a big deal of him working the most matches last year. Yeah, well he has the easiest matches to work. Making millions of dollars and still the king of minimal effort.

Right now its Seth. His recent promos against HHH strengthened him as a character at least for now, and he's the most interesting of the three at the moment.

Ambrose is one of those guys that I look at and think he would have been a much better character in the Attitude Era. His natural personality would have suited that era more and the character would have had more of an edge. Right now, he's just an idiot goofball.

And I keep saying it, but Reigns would make a great heel. The fans hate him and he comes across like a smug prick on TV. Its right there guys! But no, they have to ram him down our throats which only makes the fans hate him more.
Being a face and being "shoved down your throats" are not synonymous. Being a heel would likely not affect his push or airtime.

Also I fail to see how having some confidence after 2 years of crowds trying to tear you down is being a "smug prick". If you care to explain I'd appreciate it.
 
#23 ·
At first when the shield came up it was Ambrose. Was a huge fan of his in fcw, knew little of Reigns and thought Seth was the next Evan Bourne.

After the shield split and Seth had that epic heel run I became a huge fan of his.


Fastforward to 2017 I have not cared for Dean since 2014. Have not cared for Rollins since he turned babyface and Reigns although ive never been a fan atleast doesnt bore me atm.


So I have to go with Reigns for now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ace and DarkLady
#30 ·
I am going with Rollins, hoping that he would eventually improve to his pre-injury level.

Roman, great talent but everything depends on the creative nothing much he can do.

Dean, good talent but failed as a champion, upper card at best.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DarkLady
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top