Wrestling Forum banner

who is the most overrated female wrestler in WWE currently?

  • Natalya

    Votes: 4 1.8%
  • Nikki

    Votes: 35 16.1%
  • Brie

    Votes: 3 1.4%
  • Paige

    Votes: 58 26.6%
  • Alicia Fox

    Votes: 1 0.5%
  • Sasha

    Votes: 45 20.6%
  • Charlotte

    Votes: 51 23.4%
  • Eva Marie

    Votes: 13 6.0%
  • Other

    Votes: 9 4.1%
Status
Not open for further replies.

Who is the most overrated female wrestler in WWE currently?

11K views 112 replies 87 participants last post by  Brock 
#1 ·
It has to be Paige, right. I'd go with Paige.
 
#3 ·
Re: who is the most overrated female wrestler in WWE currently?

Eh? Heel Paige is good. Face Paige is definitely overrated.


It's between her and Charlotte. Paige is better than Charlotte but her fans also overrate her more than Charlotte fans.
 
#5 ·
Re: who is the most overrated female wrestler in WWE currently?

Face Paige. Her run was 3x worse than Charlotte's, yet she got every excuse in the book for it. Meanwhile those same people have no problem declaring Charlotte a failure, despite spending several months defending that atrocity of a title reign, and Paige's other miscellaneous mediocre face runs in general.
 
#20 ·
Re: who is the most overrated female wrestler in WWE currently?

Face Paige. Her run was 3x worse than Charlotte's, yet she got every excuse in the book for it. Meanwhile those same people have no problem declaring Charlotte a failure, despite spending several months defending that atrocity of a title reign, and Paige's other miscellaneous mediocre face runs in general.
Face Paige initially was pretty boring, however later face Paige was at least a little more bearable. Paige's run as champion was so uneventful because there weren't many/any opponents for the fans to care about until AJ came back, at least with Charlotte she has a roster full of talented women to make her boring champion persona a little more bearable.

At the moment, Charlotte is the most overrated. Yes her booking has been terrible, but she's also been terrible. Paige at the moment is doing her best work and is coming across as one of the most talented women on the roster because she's improved in all areas. I know that Charlotte can be better however right now she's been absolutely awful so far.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gsm1988
#7 · (Edited)
Re: who is the most overrated female wrestler in WWE currently?

nikki
 
#14 ·
Re: who is the most overrated female wrestler in WWE currently?

Ms. Ric Flair
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jersey
#16 ·
Re: who is the most overrated female wrestler in WWE currently?

I don't think anyone is overrated really, I think Charlotte just suffers from the lack of her own identity, but she's an athletic girl, her character I think is what's harming her at the moment, which I can kinda understand her being torn with that.
 
#27 ·
Paige, by a distance. Though some people can't seem to see past the eye shadow and push-up bra to realise it.
Paige.
Girl has gotten worse and worse and lazier as time passes. Charlotte isn't overrated mainly because people give her shit constantly.
Also this.

"I'm a different breed of diva. As in I dress and act the same way every other diva on the roster but in darker colors."
 
#21 ·
Re: who is the most overrated female wrestler in WWE currently?

I feel like people don't understand what the term 'overrated' means. If a talent is constantly being shit on, have threads calling them 'unlikable', and come out to no reaction despite their efforts, then they're not overrated.

People sucking their ass when they're even mediocre at best is being overrated.
 
#22 ·
Re: who is the most overrated female wrestler in WWE currently?

Easy, Paige. I like her, but I don't put her in a pedestal or call her an all time great. She is young and still can improve a lot, but right now, no other that her unique look, she doesn't put that much in the table.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Eva MaRIHyse
#25 ·
Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige Paige

She was good when she started and now I fear she's going to hurt someone badly in the ring cause she's lazy and botches everything (she couldn't take a backstabber correctly... All you have to do is fall backwards)

I've never been a Charlotte fan but I feel she's a lot better in the ring.
 
#29 ·
Re: who is the most overrated female wrestler in WWE currently?

Paige can't think of anything shes done that i've enjoyed since her debut. But she has hella fans and I can respect that. Everyone isn't for everybody.

Based Sasha is probably the answer for the decidely unbased people tho.
 
#30 ·
Re: who is the most overrated female wrestler in WWE currently?

It's between Charlotte and Nikki. I voted Charlotte in the poll but I think Nikki is on her way to become the most overrated diva since Charlotte gets a lot of shit these days.
I don't see how Paige can be overrated when so many people think she is shit.
 
#32 ·
Re: who is the most overrated female wrestler in WWE currently?

I'd have to go with Charlotte out of all of them. She's good, but... Her face run right now is sucking hard and i don't think she's THAT good when it comes to her wrestling.

I don't think any of them have been hyped up enough to really warrant the term 'over rated' in my eyes, though, Charlotte herself receives a lot of criticism.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gsm1988
Status
Not open for further replies.
You have insufficient privileges to reply here.
Top