Wrestling Forum banner

Do you think Michelle McCool deserves to be in the HOF?

2K views 16 replies 17 participants last post by  666_The_Game_666 
#1 ·
not saying like next year (thats sables spot then liz lol) but i definately think michelle mccool deserves to be in the hof. for a divas search contestant she wasnt some girl using wwe as a stepping stone, she was a legit fan and worked to become a great wrestler. she was part of the best divas tag team, 1st divas champion and 1st to have won the divas and womans title and the division suffered once she left.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Top Heel
#2 ·
Re: do you think michelle mccool deserves to be in the hof?

More than deserve. She is one of greatest divas in this decade. division almost non-existant after she left until divas of doom(6 months later)
 
#10 ·
Re: do you think michelle mccool deserves to be in the hof?

I hated Michelle when she was an active competitor at the time, I just thought she was handed everything because the crowd never gave a shit about her until the LayCool gimmick. Looking back at her matches after she retired made me look at her without judgement and yeah, she was actually a great wrestler but personally I wouldn't put her into the HOF. She will go in at some stage though as she's the inaugural Divas Champion (should have been Natalya) and first woman to win both the championships (should have been Mickie James). That's enough for WWE to see her as HOF worthy.
 
#11 · (Edited)
Re: do you think michelle mccool deserves to be in the hof?

She's one of the best divas recently, but NO.

The HOF should be reserved for people from DECADES ago. I'm sick of seeing recent people like Edge, Rikishi etc go in. It cheapens the prestige cause we were only watching these guys like yesterday.

On top of that, it shouldn't just be given out to anybody like Rikishi. Only former World Champions or people who were REALLY good like Mr. Perfect for example. Unfortunately they're probably lining up the likes of Kamala and The Godfather as we speak.
 
#13 ·
Re: do you think michelle mccool deserves to be in the hof?

She probably will go in, she is fairly well liked by higher ups and has the credentials. However, Michelle was one of the most overpushed Divas WWE ever had. The division suffered because quite literally all roads led to Michelle, who wasn't even all that over. She was good in the ring and a decent heel (I would have preferred that Layla be the mouth and Michelle just stay the smart muscle in that pairing), but she was never really over even after feuding with Mickie James, Melina, Kelly, and Beth/Nattie. She continued receiving a push while better heels were pushed to the background and was often allowed to incorporate their gimmicks into her own. Maryse was supposed to be the ridiculously self-involved Diva, but Laycool co-opted that.
 
#14 ·
Re: do you think michelle mccool deserves to be in the hof?

As others have said, the WWE has let mediocre at best 'superstars' in their HOF so pretty much anyone who has had more than a 3-4 year WWE career could get in. But if we're talking about a legit HOF like the other major sports have then no way do I think she should be in. She was pretty good but good ain't great.
 
#16 ·
Re: do you think michelle mccool deserves to be in the hof?

She was good, but wasn't a big enough star to be in the HOF. laycool was pretty good as far as women's tag teams go, they got a lot of screen time, but that's about it. I'm seeing in this thread that she won both the divas and women's belts in the time that they had two titles, but I don't remember a damn thing about it.

There are a lot of Divas- Torrie, Stacy, Ivory, Beth Phoenix, Mickie, or even like a Melina or Kelly Kelly (yes she was a shitty wrestler-who cares), who were far more popular stars than her.
 
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top