Right now, Curtis Axel is the worst offender. It's a shame, because out of the ring he seems really funny and charismatic, but the persona he has now just stripes him of it all.
I wasn't going to comment in this thread because I just expected a load of Curtis Axel shite .. which is bullshit, because Curtis Axel has got a lot of charisma, it's the scripts and the way he's booked that suffocates this, when you see Axel outside of the scripted work (IE ring entrances, working the crowd, his stances on the ropes, his in ring taunts, his backstage segments of him walking for his match) .... you can see very clearly that he has a lot of charisma ... I just couldn't be arsed arguing this among the people who are so set in their ways, or following a trend at the moment.
You hit the nail on the head there and you are right, even though I still don't think his booking that he has now is as bad as people make out (charisma wise), but you clearly see exactly what I'm saying here, which has surprised me (not surprised me in regards to you, but surprised me in regards to someone making the comment and 'getting it' so to speak), kudos to you!
Also, reading through this thread RetepAdam
here talks a lot of sense.