Wrestling Forum banner

Who Would Win In A Shoot Fight?

2K views 27 replies 14 participants last post by  CD Player 
#1 ·
Got this idea from another forum.

I'll post 2 names, and the next poster says who they think would win in a shoot fight. They give some brief reasoning, saying one guy has a weight advantage, a more advanced shoot fight background, or whatever.

They then list 2 more names, the next poster answers, lists 2 more names, and so forth.


First 2 names:


Kurt Angle vs. Brock Lesnar
 
#6 · (Edited)
Angle on his prime would made Lesnar tap like a bitch.

Big Show seemed more athletic than Andre so i pick him.

Joe (at his best) vs HHH
 
#7 ·
Joe surely. HHH has a body building background but those Joe kicks and chops, Jesus. Also looks to be more well versed in grappling and submissions, although prime HHH on roids would be physically stronger. Still, Joe's gonna kill ya. Don't mess with em Samoans.


BNB (bare knuckle boxer) vs Swagger (wrestler)?
 
#9 ·
Swagger would fuck Barrett up. MMA has shown that a guy with a good ground game usually gets the win over a guy with a good stand-up game.

Hull Kogan vs Sid is a toughie, but I'm going with a prime and 'roided up Hogan going over an equally 'roided Sid.

Bret Hart
HBK
 
#22 ·
Matt's wife beat him up pretty badly and Edge is a little bigger, so I'm going with Edge. I'm assuming this is both men in their prime, otherwise Matt would snap Edge's bird-like neck in a battle to the death for Lita.

Bladerunner Flash (Sting) vs Bladerunner Rock (Ultimate Warrior), anyone?
 
#23 ·
I'll pick Sting. I really don't have much to base it on. Both were roided up body builders, roughly the same size back then.

Hulk Hogan said in his book he had a celebrity boxing match with George Foreman in the early nineties. Hogan claimed he held his own against him. There's no evidence the fight ever took place.

But if it happened in the early nineties...

George Foreman vs. Hulk Hogan (explain your reasoning)
 
#24 ·
George Foreman, by the same reasoning that Butterbean knocked the crap out of Bart Gunn - Foreman is a real boxer and the Hokogan is a pro wrestler. Hulkster is trained for performance, not competition.

Plus, I don't believe that boxing story for a minute. Maybe I'm just being cynical, but this is the same guy that claimed he didn't know if André was going to put him over at WM 3.

I really like this game!

André vs Big Show
 
#26 ·
George Foreman, by the same reasoning that Butterbean knocked the crap out of Bart Gunn - Foreman is a real boxer and the Hokogan is a pro wrestler. Hulkster is trained for performance, not competition.

Plus, I don't believe that boxing story for a minute. Maybe I'm just being cynical, but this is the same guy that claimed he didn't know if André was going to put him over at WM 3.

I really like this game!


André vs Big Show
Hogan never fought Foreman. He lied.

Hogan being fearful Andre wouldn't put him over is true though, it's confirmed.



Ronda Rousey over Mayweather. On the ground she'd take over.


Bam Bam Bigelow vs. Lawrence Taylor
 
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top