re: WF Baseball Keeper League - Draft = Wed, Mar 6 @ 10pm CT. Lock keepers ASAP.
Reyes is the equivalent of Mike Vick to me. Lots of potential, but always hurt. McCutchen will be limited in his statistics because he's so easy to pitch around. Still a top 10-15 guy, but not capable of a breakout year with guys like Casey McGhee, Pedro Alvarez, and Garret Jones around him as support.
Don't think Cueto will pitch anywhere close to what he did this year. I realistically see a 3.75 ERA. Everyone knows my undeniable infatuation with Castro. Think he's the second best player in the deal behind McCutchen. I think Gonzalez is what he is. 300+ AVG, 100 RBI's, 20-28 HR's a year.
Pretty even trade, I believe. Don't see the outrage. Depends how Reyes plays next year and if he can stay healthy. Reyes wasn't hurt this year and played exceptionally well, but he doesn't have a strong track record of staying healthy. All in all, Reyes is the guy that will determine who wins, in my opinion.