Wrestling Forum banner

Rate Extreme Rules on a scale from 1-10

4K views 65 replies 61 participants last post by  RKing85 
#1 ·
I give it a 6 out of 10. What about you?
 
#2 ·
3 out 10... and that is only for Neville winning and that tag match being actual and true quality. The rest of the card was filled with lack luster matches and shit booking.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NameOfTheWind
#9 ·
I was rolling with a 7.5 out of 10 till that main event and the announcement of the pending end of Rusev's career which pretty well dropped it to a 3-10.
 
#12 ·
I give it a 1. No suspense, nothing surprising or exciting. Everything I thought would happen happened and there was no need to watch. It really might stop me from watching the main WWE shows, just so boring to me. Maybe I'll come back for Money in the Bank, that's usually fun.
 
#13 ·
WHERES THE POLL MAN?!?!

I'll give it a 4/10. It wasn't the worst PPV I've seen but nothing special happened here. Programming is just stale now though. They really need to take a look and rework the roster.
 
#14 ·
3 or 4

ambrose/harper felt incomplete for some reason (not showing 30 minutes of the match)

sheamus/ziggler - stipulation was meaningless

new day/kidcesaro - great match

john cena/rusev - they kicked lana out... wtf

nikki/naomi - lol at naomi's outfit also confusing how bella twins are face now even though they cheat for a win

roman reigns/big show - not a bad match but we've seen it many many times before

seth rollins/randy orton - just plain boring
 
#16 ·
7/10

Harper/Ambrose - 7/10 - no tables? really?
Ziggler(or as JBL says 'Zigger')/Sheamus - 8/10 - MOTN
Cesaro and Kidd/New Day - 7/10 - NEW DAY!
Cena/Rusev - 6.5/10 - Was what it was
Nikki/Naomi - 6/10 - Glowing shoes
Reigns/Show - 7.5/10 - Entertaining ..... but too many tables
Rollins/Orton - 7.5/10 - Dragged but good ending

Also, apparently Ambrose and Harper went on for 56:10. :lmao
 
#17 · (Edited)
6 out of 10.

*** - Bad News Barrett vs. Neville
***1/4 - Chicago Street Fight: Dean Ambrose vs. Luke Harper
**1/4 - "Kiss Me Arse" match: Dolph Ziggler vs. Sheamus
***1/2 - WWE Tag Team Championship: New Day vs. Kidd & Cesaro (c)
**1/2 - United States Championship: John Cena(c) vs. Rusev
*3/4 - Divas Championship: Nikki Bella(c) vs. Naomi
***1/2 - Last Man Standing match: Roman Reigns vs. Big Show
**3/4 - Steel Cage match: Seth Rollins(c) vs. Randy Orton
 
#18 ·
5/10. The undercard shined with a great tag match, an awesome affair from Neville/Barrett, and an entertaining segment for Harper and Ambrose.

The main event stuff fell flat, exception was Show/Reigns which was not too shabby.
 
#21 ·
- Didn't see Barrett vs Neville.

- Ambrose vs Harper was fun, very unorthodox, but the finish was kind of weak.

- Ziggler vs Sheamus was a great match, minus the awful crap post-finish

- The tag-team match was awesome. MOTN.

- Cena can have really good matches when he wants to, but tonight was not the case. It was awful.

- I saw too little of the divas match to comment : couldn't give a flying fuck about The Bellas and Naomi.

- Reigns vs Big Show was better than expected. Still pretty bad and mostly horribly boring, but at least entertaining on some parts, thanks to the spotfest, gotta give them that.

- Bo/Ryback almost had me thinking I was watching RAW. Pointless.

- The ME was... underwhelming to say the least. Incredibly overbooked, but that was to be expected anyway. Though, I got to say that even during the "normal" parts, the wrestling wasn't even that good. Pace didn't pick up, and when it was about to, the overbooking began. The RKO finish has me hoping they're still thinking of a new finisher for Rollins though, and that's great.

I'd give it a 6,5/10 overall. The first hour was ace, but the main event really wasn't good, and that's definately gotta have a big impact on my appreciation of the show.
 
#26 ·
:lmao this forum

9/10, nearly a 10/10. Great matches. The only match that lacked was the main event, and considering the broke the "NO RKO" rule to finish...whatever.

If you like wrestling, then you should have liked this PPV. If you like complaining, then you're probably just complaining.
 
#27 ·
Here's the sad fact of today's WWE: the tag match and the Neville match weren't ground breakingly great, but they are the reason people are saying ER was anything other than boring/awful. They were just great in comparison to the rest of the card, and better than anyone expected of them. In other words, the audience expecting crap is the norm now, and anything above average is going to be rated higher than it normally should simply because we're used to expecting said crap.
 
#29 ·
Don't fully agree since I think that tag match was a legit good to great match, but pretty much. I see so many 7 or aboves thrown out for these PPVs and **** ratings for mediocre matches that it just makes me wonder if some people only watch today's WWE and haven't seen true greatness.
 
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top