Wrestling Forum banner

TDL XI: MANY A PRINCE, BUT ONLY ONE A KING - THE CARD

17K views 374 replies 35 participants last post by  Dr. Ian Malcolm 
#1 ·
TDL XI: MANY A PRINCE, BUT ONLY ONE A KING

CHAMPviaDQ

THE REMATCH
THE DARK ANDRE vs DDMac

Who had the greater impact on professional wrestling, Hulk Hogan or Steve Austin?

PM Debates To [USER]Headliner[/USER]

TDL Wrestling Division #1 Contenders Match - 4 Way Eliminator: Stage 2
ZOMBO vs STEVIE SWAG vs samizayn

Which member of The Shield will have the most successful singles career?

PM Debates To [USER]Headliner[/USER]

TDL Sports Division #1 Contenders Match
BkB Hulk vs Kiz

Who should win the 2013 FIFA Ballon D'Or?

PM Debates To [USER]Headliner[/USER]

Put The Fuck Up Or Shut The Fuck Up II
The Lady Killer vs Scott Hall's Ghost

Is the notion that Sting was a big star false?

PM Debates To [USER]THE DARK ANDRE[/USER]

LUCK vs Rush
Who is the better center in the NBA right now, Dwight Howard or Roy Hibbert?

PM Debates To [USER]Seabs[/USER]

CGS vs CamillePunk vs Jupiter Jack Daniels vs TheLoneShark
Should WWE do an 8 man one night only elimination tournament on PPV in 2014?

PM Debates To [USER]The Lady Killer[/USER]

DestrosSecret vs BOLO YEUNG vs TehJerichoFan vs Tater
Does the internet bring more harm than good?

PM Debates To [USER]Seabs[/USER]

IJ vs Notorious vs Darth Cock
Was the punishment handed out to Richie Incognito for his part in the Miami Dolphins bullying scandal the right course of action to take?

PM Debates To [USER]Seabs[/USER]

TAR vs Bullseye vs ashes11 vs Comedy Inc
Has the introduction of T20 come at the detriment of Test Cricket?

PM Debates To [USER]The Lady Killer[/USER]

DwayneAustin vs Desecrated
Should Andre Villas Boas have been given more time as Tottenham manager?

PM Debates To [USER]Seabs[/USER]

The Wrestling Junkie vs RichardHagen vs killacamt vs AwShit
Assuming that Batista is indeed confirmed for Wrestlemania, who should his opponent(s) be?

PM Debates To [USER]WOOLCOCK[/USER]

MoveMent vs RMSTGO vs Alim vs Klunderbunker
What should be the WWE World Heavyweight Title match for Royal Rumble?

PM Debates To [USER]WOOLCOCK[/USER]

Lane vs doinktheclowns vs The Fourth Wall vs OXI
Vince McMahon has decided he's going to push one of Cody Rhodes & Dolph Ziggler to be one of his top babyfaces in the company. Which should he choose?

PM Debates To [USER]The Lady Killer[/USER]

  • Deadline for all debates is January 10th 13:00 GMT. Basically January 10th at the time of this post. Any no shows WILL RESULT IN PERMANENT EXCLUSION FROM THE LEAGUE.
  • If you need to withdraw then please PM me and let us know.
  • In the event that someone pulls out we will replace them on the card with another user.
  • Please make sure you only submit your debate by PMing it to the intended recipient stated above. Don't post them anywhere on the forum. The debates will be forwarded onto the selected judging panel for your debate anonymously. When I post the results show you'll know what user posted each debate along with the judging panel for each debate.
  • Minimum word count = 300, Maximum word count = 800.
    For Title Matches
    Minimum word count = 500, Maximum word count = 1000.
  • You are free to debate either side of an argument. Your choice.
  • NO BLATANT PLAGIARISM
 
See less See more
1
#316 ·
^ no tl;dr needed Tater, that basically sums up my feelings about this thing since Day 1, where I was fortunate enough to be included as a replacement on the opening card. I remember getting the add, and then immediately dropping everything, writing the debate and sending it in within a couple hours. Never cared how long the wait is, since each debate is a learning tool for the next one and I prefer the nit-picking comments rather than a bland overview.

I never forget that these judges are just people with real actual lives, and that analyzing multiple debates on a wrestling forum may not be priority #1 every single day. It's just super cool that this stuff is happening in the first place.
 
#30 ·
Agreed with Seabs. If you two wanted to do debates in your own time and maybe have a few judges give brief feedback, then I wouldn't mind. But despite being 'fun', the question is so ridiculous in its premise I'm not sure how Zombo could realistically put forward an entry that Andre wouldn't obliterate with even the most half arsed approach.

I think the whole concept behind TDL is trying to encourage an even balance that gives both sides an equal chance to submit something capable of victory. It's a fun question given the Zombo/Hull love affair that's developed in the chatbox, but I'd feel uneasy having that as an actual debate on a card given how different it is from your standard debate.
 
#32 ·
I really wouldn't mind juding it if you two went about it in your own time and perhaps just PM'd three people your debates, something disconnected from TDL in terms of wins/losses and just a bit of fun. That I jave no mither with. I just find the question a bit too unrealistic that it would basically render your chances to an absolutely minimal (and that's being kind) degree, which really seems to go against what TDL has been about since it's return :eek:
 
#66 ·
No seriously, I know nothing about Sting. I thought I said I wanted WWE only. :mad:
If this is the case, then I guess I'm fine with changing the topic. I've only written a sloppy first-pass of some general ideas so far, and there's enough time before deadline to go at the debate fresh, so if Greg is stumped on this one, why don't we just switch it up? Seeing as it's a grudge match, I guess it should be something we're both on the ball about to let us both put out something we can stand behind.

I'm easy, just let me know.
 
#95 ·
Debate is in, very easy write - I just said it how it is, there was not much research that was needed seeing as it was a personal opinion. Interesting to see others response is to the topic, but I think I was able to make some quick precise judgments on who Batista opponent should be. Great topic, enjoyed writing it - not expecting big things from it, but it's a fair debate I put in.
 
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top