Re: Who could have been a Horseman?
No for me on Tommy Rich, he did not have the type of charisma the Horsemen needed. However as long as Ric, Arn and Tully were the other three I would say they could have played just about anyone off as a Horseman.
But, people who would have made good Horsemen, they are few and far between. There was only one Flair and Bockwinkel or DiBiase would have been too much like him.
Considering the time period I would think Terry Taylor, Paul Orndorff, Ken Patera (he would have been awesome as the Horseman muscle), or even Billy Jack Haynes (it's a stretch but I can see him in a suit).