Well, firstly I just realized it was actually firefox.
Anyways, it's this:
The thing that's in the black circle. I have no idea why it's not implemented in Safari or Chrome, but it works like a gem for me with FF. I write in the format that I want it in via Word, press that button and copy-paste, make a few adjustments with the spacing since there's usually problems, and presto.
"I wrestled that match with Undertaker at WrestleMania with the biggest f*cking chip on my shoulder because I knew it was going to be better than Brock Lesnar vs. Triple H and The Rock vs. John Cena."