To be fair, anything set in the 2005/2006 period is (almost always) automatically redundant because it's been done so many times before. 2006 moreso than 2005.
I'd really love to see someone take on an entire "year" in wrestling terms, from WrestleMania X-Seven to WrestleMania X8. That's one period I've always considered going back to but never have. It'd be interesting to see how someone could book that entire year, 2001, as so much happened in it. Austin's heel turn, the Invasion angle, Angle's face turn, the return of Triple H, as well as a whole bunch of current WWE stars waiting to be called up to the main roster from OVW.
Dammit, just tempted myself.