Awesome show, edgehead. I'll review match by match.
First off, great opening segment. Both Cena and HBK were in character and a potential Cena/HBK match would definately shape up Wrestlemania.
Big Show vs. Eugene - Uh, duh?
Big Show looks to be dominant and the favorite to win right now. Just keep his dominance intact.
HHH and HBK showing respect. What I liked about this segment was that it wasn't over the top corny but it didn't hint any turns or dissents. It was just a true matter of respect and it accomplished what it accomplished.
Orton vs. Carlito - Again, another squash. Orton, I guess, got his win but I actually thought Carlito may have done a surprise win. Oh well.
Angle made me lol with his promo on Edge. Angle still rebounds from his loss from H by attacking verbally Edge. Nice.
Angle vs. Dykstra - Squash, basically. Edge attacking Angle was predictable but did what it needed to do by making Edge a huge heel and attacking one of the top faces.
Hardy vs. Edge - Which led to this match. I actually though Angle would cause Edge the match but UMAGA comes out and takes out Jeff Hardy, making Edge go to the EC while Jeff retains his IC belt. A unique finish there.
Nitro vs. Crazy - Another predictable match. I gotta say, these elimination chamber qualifiers sounds like easy wins. I mean, maybe you could have had two squashes but I kinda expected then other competative matches between two superstars. Felt like I knew the results each time.
HBK vs. HHH - MOTN obviously which establishes HBK's road to becoming WWE champion but doesn't make HHH look weak at all. Cena at the end telling HBK may the best man win tells me we're in for a great match at NWO.
Overall, a great debut show for your thread, edgehead. The matches were pretty okay up untill the main event. You had great segments and you setted up feuds that should carry all the way to Wrestlemania and even beyond that. Great job and I'll be reading this thread from now on.
PS: By the way, make sure you review my latest Horizon show if you have the chance.