Glad to see this is coming back, I am currently in the process of quickly scanning through this thread from 20 pages onwards, so I can get an idea of everything that has happened. I did read this about a year ago but then left these forums for half a year so loads probably happened during that time. Would you be able to post your rosters so we know whose on which show.
I would disagree with both of you. SmackDown has far superior main event quality than RAW. RAW has better mid card quality but SmackDown also has the Cruisers and a great Tag Division which does it for me. I also used to prefer SD! to RAW back in the day when Wolfie would write full time.
I see the main event picture getting better as it seems like Wolfy is going to push Randy Orton back up to the main eventers. Also Christian, Rey Mysterio, and Batista seem to be heads up there also. So I see RAW actually being better for the main event area because of those pushes.
"Acquire a peaceful spirit, and around you thousands will be saved." + Saint Seraphim of Sarov
RAW may have people being 'pushed into main event status' but SmackDown already has established main eventers. It's one thing pushing someone but having established stars still there is a totally different ball game.
Thats true Showstopper, and I am not too knowledgable about the entire past of this so wouldn't be able to say about previous RAW/SmackDown. I am, however, up to page 40 of scanning through and this is looking great.