Re: Mafia Host List + General Discussion
In your case Lostfap, I was confused as to how you were done the game but didn't have a name. When you signup, I expect that you have a theme prepared (NOT NECESSARILY A NAME) and that preparation for the game (all of your roles listed, started writing roles, etc.) has begun.
I've done this so that people aren't constantly signing up just to reserve themselves a spot. MetalX got lucky because he still had time to change his theme and prepare the game.