However lynching him
while he's silenced is poor play, as it gives us no chance to hear a claim and weigh it up, thus it's esentially a blind lynch.
As for your points:
1)He's not the only one.
2)Didn't you say I had an opinion
too early? This isn't really a point against him per se.
3) Eh not the only one, thus meh. Plus WIFOM either way.
4)Eh rude =/= scummy
5) Oh I think both CBR and Retep are innocent at the moment, so I don't see them as defending him.
Either way we're off to a very good start, let's not blow it plz. NO innocents dead to begin is pretty damn lucky, so yeh.

.
Vote stands on the thunderman, not sure I like Nov's vote, something about the way it's written rubs me the wrong way.
Kantos has read the thread and offered no thoughts.
CBR should clarify if he's bulletproof, he can't be killed either way or the killer will be silenced

Haha so he's as good as
