Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Spartanlax
First off, you haven't seen the match, so you can't really say whether my comments are warranted or not. Having a different opinion is one thing, being wrong is another. That reviewer is wrong, not just with the rating, but with his comments about the arm work and such: it did lead somewhere, it lead to arm submissions and an attempt at a submission victory, durr. Also, the only reason you've grown to hate that is because you receive the hate yourself, am I right? And I say it's deserved, you blatantly let your like/dislike for wrestlers change your ratings, among other things.
|
How did I know I was gonna get owned there? You are the best arguer ever Spart. (no sarcasm, I'm being serious)
Anyway...
Sure I haven't seen the match, but that doesn't stop me from saying the "you need to get your head checked out" comment is out of line. Maybe he just didn't see/pay attention to/notice the armwork leading to somewhere.
It seems you think differenet, but to me a rating is never right or wrong, as it's opinion. There is no "right" rating for a match, as the rating is opinon, not fact.
Now, let me distinctly say I
do not hate those comments because they're used against me. I've never had them used against me, or at least not a personal insult. There's a difference between "your review sucks" and saying "you suck". Anyway, I've never had any of those kind of comments used on me. But I have read them elsewhere, and it annoys me that fellow reviewers are being disrespected. People take time to review things, and help people on their decision on buying the show - they shouldn't be personally insulted for that.
Criticizing my reviews is fine, but there really was no need for that here, as all I did was complain about you insulting some dude for his rating, without anything to do with my reviews.
EDIT: If Gabe broke Kayfabe and all at Main Event Spectacles and told Teddy hart never to work for ROH again, how come Teddy was book at 2004's "At Our Best"?