I always liked no mercy "survival" match or what ever it was, where if you got far enough you unlocked guys
not really a rumble how ever
One of the first SvR had where you could "toss" people out by doing a lot of normal moves... Really liked that, probably be my fav but dont remember which year.
I enjoy the survival mode definitely, little feuds develop mid-match and stuff. I was playing forever Indy recently and I was CM Punk in this match, with I think Jay Briscoe, Joey Ryan and Toby Klein as the other 3 at the beginning. I got to about 20 but amazingly Toby Klein was still in the match, so I made it my mission to protect him as long as I could. I think I got to about 35 and the fucker pinned me. Enjoyed it immensely.
Also really enjoyed things like Super Powerbombing somebody out of the ring, or an over the top belly to belly. Classics.