Wrestling Forum : WWE, TNA, Indy Wrestling, Lucha Underground, Women of Wrestling Forums - View Single Post - Official Puro Match/DVD Discussion Thread (NO SPOILERS)

View Single Post
post #5209 of (permalink) Old 01-24-2013, 10:05 AM
Wheelman for James Ellsworth
MF83's Avatar
Join Date: Jan 2012
Location: "I'm from Winnipeg, you idiot!"
Posts: 682
Points: 0
Re: Official Puro Match/DVD Discussion Thread (NO SPOILERS)

Shinya Hashimoto vs. Naoya Ogawa

(4/12/97) http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature...&v=aXLu8l43of4
(5/3/97) http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature...&v=a_WqyApumDk
(1/4/99) http://www.nicovideo.jp/watch/sm3130046 http://www.nicovideo.jp/watch/sm3131336 http://www.nicovideo.jp/watch/sm3135788
(10/11/99) http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature...&v=MZrcfcUZK_8
(4/7/00) http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature...&v=6oHGGPokqj8 http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature...&v=Ey6gEjXk5sI

Beware the spoilers! Some very important history:

Shinya Hashimoto was the ace of NJPW. By some measures, his 1996-1997 IWGP reign is the highest grossing title reign anywhere, ever. Naoya Ogawa is an Olympic silver medalist in Judo who was originally brought into NJPW for a "Different Style Fight" in a non-title match against the champ during his blockbuster reign. What became of the feud is some of the worst booking/backstage bullshit to ever happen in pro wrestling, but it brought with it awesome matches. This was the beginning of 'Inokism', the bizarre chain of events stemming from Antonio Inoki's bright idea that MMA and Pro Wrestling could become a mixed entity... somehow.

So Ogawa comes in for his special non-title match with the champ, wearing his gi and taking a licking before shocking the audience by unleashing his dreaded STO and following up with a choke sleeper for the win. He earns himself a title shot a month later and Hashimoto gets his win back to retain his title. Ogawa sticks around and loses to Muta and Don Frye a couple of times and scores a couple of smaller victories. After retiring in 1998, Antonio Inoki decided to open UFO, an MMA promotion. Ogawa would train with Satoru Sayama and others in the ways of MMA. He punched president Seiji Sakaguchi at a conference, quit NJPW and joined UFO. Booker Riki Choshu vowed that NJPW would quit supporting UFO. Ogawa was scheduled for a rubber match with Hashimoto on 1/4/99 and in an effort to gain publicity and legitimacy for UFO, Inoki convinced Ogawa to take liberties with and beat the shit out of Hashimoto. Hashimoto was unaware he was about to be shot on and would end up being hospitalized after the match. This one-sided ass-kicking tarnished his character and NJPW in general. (Enuhito's youtube video explaining 1.4 Incident in detail: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VveLsHFoUcg)

Somehow, everyone agreed that they would fight again, this time for the NWA Title. Inoki had the decision changed again at the last minute and instead of giving their former ace the revenge victory he so desperately needed, they had him go down decidedly in an albeit classic match and finish. They had a tag match at the January 4th, 2000 Dome show and afterwards, Hashimoto wanted yet another match with the stipulation that if he lost, he would retire. He shaved his hair for the match and he lost once again!

Hashimoto was initially going to return as the leader of a NJPW offshoot stable but more backstage drama left him creating ZERO1-MAX. Ironically, Ogawa would join Zero1 and be the number two star before leading the HUSTLE revolution and inevitably going back to Inoki under the IGF banner. Inoki would continue to be insane and almost killed New Japan.


1. (10/11/99) - I watched this twice. The first time through left me questioning if it even broke the four star threshold. However, I knew my view was tainted knowing I had allowed myself to come in dismissive and sucked into mark anger over the 1/4 incident and at the monumental stupidity of the booking here. "Let's take our ace, tainted by getting his ass handed to him unprofessionally in an infamous shoot incident... and job him to the exact same guy!" As well, the shift in atmosphere from "fuck yeah! Different Style FIGHT!" to "Okay, let's pretend this is real!" was uncomfortably present. I wanted to counter some things Daniel said in my writeup and without specific examples, watched it again I did.

I appreciated their callbacks to the 1/4 incident in worked form even more on the second view. That headbutt spot was fucking perfect. I'd actually agree with almost everything Daniel said about the match with the exception of his description of Ogawa's selling. Not that it was less than good or even great, but it was a little inconsistent towards the end and not of the general quality needed to be dubbed on par with the best selling ever. That's about it for my stubborn nitpicking though. What I paid more attention to the second time through was the final section, specifically Ogawa's cut-offs and the miniature hope spots Hashimoto would squeeze in. The layout is stunningly intricate and Hashimoto rivals Terry Funk in expressiveness; I'd argue it even more impressive because it was not cartoon-like nor a trademark of himself. On top of that, he had to call the match for the most part, something Terry rarely did. Hashimoto expertly executing his role deserves an Oscar equivalent for how perfectly he played it. Keys to the match's success were Ogawa's timing, facials, selling and cooperation with Hashimoto's work. Props given where due. ★★★★★ or 90%

2. (4/7/00) - I also watched this twice. Hashimoto's performance in this match is chilling. If he won the 1999 Terry Funk award for expression, he sure as shit retained in 2000. Speaking of Terry Funk, this reminds me of Terry's initial retirement match in how Hashimoto wrestles as if it really were his last match. His attitude, language and aura in general is unique to any of his matches. He comes in with dead eyes and he dominates. He is there to survive and to destroy, not to fight. He has an answer to everything Ogawa throws at him. The apron suimengiri and STO->DDT counters are up there with the suimengiri from the Takada match in terms of highlight reel moments, and a bunch of other counters added so much. Flaws to the match include the opening portion of the bout being weak, the pacing was a bit off in the first half, an overall weaker Ogawa performance and the bewildering Murakami interference spot. Although bit more microscopic, Hashimoto defenselessly giving into the first STO that would begin Ogawa's career ending string of offense, given that the superbly demonstrated psychological theme of the match was Hashimoto's preparation and focus to prevent and adapt to all things threatening, was a glaringly poor transition the second time through. The feud's climax is transcendent. Without its flaws this match surpasses their fourth match. As it is, ****3/4 or 87%

3. (5/3/97) - Essentially a collection of callback spots from their first match worked a lot tighter and more interestingly so than in match #1. The final stretch is wrestling gold. The good kind of unsatisfying; the kind that begs for more. 78%

4. (4/12/97) - 60% Ogawa looks fine for a debut match. He still has an air of humility about him and Hash backpacks him to something acceptable.

5. (1/4/99) - "Cancerous to the industry" It's shoot-shaky and troubling from the get go. Ogawa unleashes a barrage of cheap shots that did hospitalizing injury. Awkward and abominable. The aftermath was fun for me waiting for Choshu to punch Ogawa. 5% for entertainment factor.

Bonus: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hsyu9s3qiNM http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gnurR2X7X0o
(1/4/2000) Hashimoto/Iizuka vs. Ogawa/Murakami - Murakami's sloppiness brings with it shoot atmospheric excitement and this match is wacky chaos. The way it works out is as if they tried displaying the deteriorating 'health' of the seconds la some video game and it was wicked to see. Ogawa only tagged in once Murakami truly needed the tag, and that kind of logic doesn't usually apply. The build to the clash of the titans is what the match is about and like I said, it was done exceptionally well. It all breaks down in the end as Hashimoto applies a double wrist lock on the floor (professional wrestling!) and Iizuka earns himself a humongous win. Hashimoto probably needed the fall but this was a damn good Dome spectacle. ★★★★ or so.

Last edited by MF83; 01-24-2013 at 12:11 PM.
MF83 is offline  
For the best viewing experience please update your browser to Google Chrome