Re: Who would win a modern day Brawl For All?
Are we sticking with the ethos of the original Brawl for All? I.e. it was meant to be for people who weren't featuring regularly on the main roster?
If not I'd go with Alberto Del Rio- he looks legit tough and has amateur skills as well as MMA background. Barrett would be another good choice I think seeing as the original BFA turned into a bit of a slog-fest with guys like Dan Severn and Steve Blackman getting really frustrated at the scores. Obviously Lesnar would be a huge favourite too but, then again, the favourites faired really badly in the original.
If it was just for guys who aren't involved in main storylines I'd go with Swagger or possibly Santino- I hear he has some pretty solid shoot skills too.
Layla, Daffney, Beth Phoenix. What more could a guy want?