I do not have a gentle heart.
Join Date: Jan 2007
Re: Christmas Mafia 2012 Gameplay Thread
Okay, it sounds like Roger is most likely town then because he wouldn't have been able to see that the BG protected Magic if he were scum. I think I'm following everything correctly now. I wonder if Roger was trying to out the Town BG though. Hmmm, it sounds like too wild of a gambit. Usually when one comes up with a complicated theory it's wrong so at this point it seems like he's town. I'd like to know all his role usage if he survives the night.
I wasn't arguing that scum have a voyeur but rather weighing all possibilities. It's not like that's impossible even though I haven't seen that before. I like to think outside of the box.