Acknowledged by SCOTT STEINER
Join Date: Jan 2012
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 0 Post(s)
Re: WrestlingForum TV Hall of Fame
I was sceptical about allowing running shows to be eligible but then that would make a show like The Simpsons ineligible and that's silly. 3 Seasons should be a fairly good indication of if a show is worthy or not. Hopefully. Like you said I want this to be as elite as it can feasibly be so if it does get overcrowded then I'll adjust the criteria. You can always change your vote if a show like Mad Men goes to pot in the remaining seasons.
Nomination list updated.
The Thick Of It
You can nominate more than one show you know.
Didn't think Extras was HOF level. 1st season of Prison Break was easy HOF level but the rest certainly wasn't. If there was a wing for seasons then Prison Break Season 1 would be one of my top votes.
1st entrant - Breaking Bad
I can understand your point of view but as a series i thought it was excellent The first 2 seasons were near perfect and it had possibly one of the best and most fitting end to a series i have seen.
I would say no to Lost because I really didn't care for it, but I can see why it'd be in a TV HOF.
This reasoning seems a bit ridiculous because over half the shows i didn't care for on the nominated list it doesn't mean i should down vote them for that reason.