Re: WF MAFIA (Night One)
Actually a cop counterclaiming Day 1 would be sub optimal play IMO. You'd investigate night 1 and get a result, then counterclaim. You only lose a day, which isn't much in a large game + you get the interactions of the scum posting as the cop + you get your result. It's worth it in the hope you get a second guilty. Basically, the worst that can happen is you get killed and flip cop and then he gets lynched anyway. Well, the worst would be you get janitored and killed but that's a fairly unrealistic scenario so w/e.
Cop should never claim immeditately with a result in theory, anyway but that never happens.