The cop isn't going to counter-claim day one though... at least I wouldn't think he/she would.
Why not? If you're a cop and you catch scum on Night 1 you're going to admit that you caught them and put a huge target on your back. Same thing if someone counter claimed him today. It's a 1-for-1 trade and most people here should be willing to make that trade.
I'm not going to cop anyone night one though Mikey.
I'm only LIMITED.
If this is true you're the worst. We can keep you alive via BG or watch you and make scum lose someone if they go after you but eventually they're going to get you so let's just hope you can use all 2 of your shots before you die.