Originally Posted by Faraday
Did I say it was scummy?
(Not that I didn't strongly imply it, but still!)
I think it's pointless, since if he's completely new he'll be easyish to read by letting him play naturally (I think) as he'll probably just respond with confusion to a vote before he posted as town or scum. You should do it after he posts. I dunno, it felt like the type of vote you might be more likely to make as scum. I also think not explaining it means he_just_won't_get_it so renders the test less useful again.
it's a vote ive made before and it's one i like making because new people are more likely to react to a random vote than someone who's played before. whether or not i learn anything from it is another thing but i certainly wouldnt call it pointless. if i was scum surely it'd be better to wait until he posts and then try and build an easy case from that?
i mean its lost all use now with me having to explain it but whatever.
Originally Posted by dan the marino
Rising and Kratos are playing again?
On agree with Skyfall on Faraday jumping around between votes, that's sort of odd for him. Shepard voting the new guy is also a bit strange.
me voting the new guy is strange how? it's not like it's the first time ive done it.