Re: Official DVD/Match/Show Discussion Thread
I reviewed a shit load of women's PPV matches from that time period (07-09) earlier in this thread. I can't remember the rating I gave Melina/McCool's title match from NOC but I enjoyed it. There aren't a lot McCool fans but I liked her and thought she was a really good worker (though I vastly prefer her babyface work). Her & Maryse had a great title match on ECW back in 08. I also liked her match with Natalya from GAB. Didn't like her heel turn nor did I like LayCool.
CM Punk goes to Wrestlemania!
Quick Thoughts: Punk put together a strong string of WM performances, they still hold up very well.
CM Punk vs. Kennedy vs. Edge vs. Orton vs. Booker vs. Finlay vs. Matt vs. Jeff (Wrestlemania 23) – ****1/2
CM Punk vs. Kennedy vs. Jericho vs. MVP vs. Benjamin vs. Morrison vs. Carlito (Wrestlemania XXIV) – ****
CM Punk vs. Kane vs. Henry vs. Finlay vs. Benjamin vs. Kofi vs. MVP vs. Christian (Wrestlemania 25) – ***1/2
CM Punk vs. Rey Mysterio (Wrestlemania XXVI) – ***1/2
CM Punk vs. Randy Orton (Wrestlemania XXVII) – ***3/4+
CM Punk vs. Chris Jericho (Wrestlemania XXVIII) – ***1/2 (don’t shoot me)
I Matt Hardy (A Matt Hardy guy since '99):
*=meh **=decent/average ***=good ****=very good *****=outstanding