Originally Posted by Modern
I didn't say he wouldn't be a top star because of him being over the top, i'm saying that he is not going to be a top star because of his gimmick.
I don't see how his character prevents him from being a top star. Fucking psycho Randy Orton got cheered by the fans and became the #2 babyface in WWE at one point. If it has anything to do with his mannerisms then you're still wrong Jack Sparrow and Heath Ledger's Joker are two of the most popular characters in all of media over the past decade, both are odd in certain ways and spaz out a lot.
I don't really think you have an argument.