Originally Posted by Seb
Nadal has had Federer in his pocket for years
He also hasn't finished his career and could well bank another 7 or 8 slams.
He's also had much more competition than Federer had when he was winning a huge chunk of his slams - i.e. Fed himself, as well as Djokovic, even Murray is a better player than Roddick, JCF and, erm, whoever else was losing in finals.
Winning the most doesn't automatically make you the GOAT either, not many people consider Schumacher a better driver than Senna despite the latter winning less titles.
I said hopefully he does not overtake Federer. Yeah that is true but i am sure you consider Federer to be the GOAT atm. He was incredible. He owned his opponents in the finals. The only one who could challenge him at that time was Marat Safin.
Murray is not better than Hewitt or Safin when they were in their prime. Not yet.