I have a document I keep that I grade in entertainment value instead of match quality since that's what actually matters to me. I have ~70 matches at 5*.
A match I never see get pimped as 5* is Jimmy Jacobs vs BJ Whitmer in a cage at SCoH II. That had loads of story in it and did it's job as a blowoff match as Jacobs loses a tooth and sustains an injury that keeps him out 9 months afterwards. It's sick. I may have to upload that.
I have yet to see the third match between Strong and Danielson but I have it upped already and I've seen it on people's list itt.
Danielson vs Strong @ SCoH